When Sarah Michelle Gellar took to her Instagram page in February 2025 to announce that a Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot was in development at Hulu with Chloé Zhao directing the pilot, it was music to the ears of fans who have been waiting years for some kind of return of the iconic genre series.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer has maintained a loyal and dedicated fanbase since its 1997 premiere. With so many TV shows and movies getting the legacy sequel treatment, the series was perfect for a relaunch. Gellar has been protective of the brand for years and didn’t want to move forward unless things were perfect and she was on board, and fans felt a sense of comfort that somebody would protect the IP. The pilot for the reboot, which Gellar has said is more of a sequel series, tentatively titled Buffy: New Sunnydale, went into production in August 2025 and would feature a new slayer, portrayed by Ryan Kiera Armstrong, with Gellar’s Buffy returning as a mentor of sorts.

It seemed as if things were moving smoothly until the shocking news that Hulu would not proceed with the project. Since the announcement, there have been a mix of official statements from Gellar and Zhao about what led to the decision. Still, there’s been chatter about the pilot’s quality and whether that was the reason Hulu wasn’t all-in on it. With so much out there about how all of this happened, let’s break down what could’ve gone wrong behind the scenes to kill Buffy’s return to the small screen.

Buffy: New Sunnydale Behind the Scenes

News of Hulu’s decision broke on Saturday during a time that was certainly awkward for some of the creatives behind the series. Gellar learned of the news on Friday night while attending the SXSW premiere of her new film, Ready or Not 2: Here I Come. The actress was promoting the film at the event. She enthusiastically spoke to various press about the Buffy reboot, clearly unaware that Hulu was preparing to pass on the project.

As for Zhao, the director was in the middle of a busy weekend herself, attending the Academy Awards for her film Hamnet, which landed her a second Oscar nomination for Best Director, and the film was nominated for Best Picture. To say the timing of the decision was questionable is a bit of an understatement given the fact that Ready or Not 2: Here I Come is a Searchlight release, which Gellar was in the midst of promoting, and they, along with Hulu and 20th TV, are owned by Disney, which holds the Buffy rights. What should’ve been a big weekend of celebration for all involved was stained by the news, and then it turned into: what exactly went wrong to prompt a definitive, seemingly abrupt decision?

Gellar and Zao Statements

Gellar clarified some points during an interview with People, suggesting the decision blindsided many. The actress said, “No one saw this coming, including the head of Searchlight, and I got the call as we were stepping onto the stage for the premiere of their own movie.”

Gellar got even more pointed when she said an executive at Hulu was not a fan of the original series and had not seen the entire series, something he seemed proud of.

“We had an executive on our show who was not only not a fan of the original, but was proud to constantly remind us that he had never seen the entirety of the series and how it wasn’t for him. That’s very hard when you’re taking a property that is as beloved as Buffy, not just to the world, but to me and Chloé. So that tells you the uphill battle that we had been fighting since day one, when your executive is literally proud to tell you he didn’t watch it.”

What Happens Now?

During the interview, Gellar didn’t name the executive, but it has since been revealed that it was Disney Television Group President Craig Erwich, who oversees Hulu originals. Once clarifying who made the final call, fans were quick to take to social media to demand his resignation. Fans are wondering how someone could pass on the continuation of a beloved IP, but once the dust settled, more clarification emerged about the decision, and this wasn’t an issue where a single problem lay at its heart.

According to Deadline, the original pilot, written by Nora and Lilla Zuckerman and produced in August 2025, had issues Hulu wanted addressed. Some assessments said it was “not perfect,” while others went so far as to say it was “not great.” The powers that be at Hulu believed the pilot seemed too young and felt too “small” for the streaming service, suggesting it was better suited to network TV than to Hulu.

Deadline wiesely points out that the pilot went through development, greenlight, casting, and production without any of these issues being addressed, which seems odd for a potential high-profile series for the streamer. Even more confusing is that the mandate for the pilot was to maintain the spirit of the original show, which aired on network TV via The WB for its first five seasons and then UPN for its final two. If that were the show’s business goal, the notes Hulu received would contradict what they wanted from the show. If what was desired needed elaboration, it should’ve been addressed during the various phases of its development.

What About These Critiques?

The show playing too young was an interesting critique because Hulu didn’t step in when Armstrong, who was 15 at the time of her casting, was brought on as the new slayer. Her age alone should’ve been a big indication that the show was going to skew a bit younger, with the opportunity to grow more adult if it had continued, much like the original did. 

While Gellar was 18 when cast in the original pilot, Buffy the Vampire Slayer was still a teen series whose first three seasons depicted her balancing high school with defending Sunnydale from vampires and other demons, before subsequent seasons charted her growth beyond that point until its conclusion after seven seasons.

The notes seemed to be taken in stride, however, and the Zuckermans went back to the drawing board to address the streamer’s concerns and did a rewrite. According to reports, the new pilot was about 90 minutes and was much more adult in its approach. It also featured more of Gellar’s Buffy, probably addressing another concern that, despite this being a show about the passing of the torch, she remained the biggest selling point. There was also that note about the show feeling “too small.” 

Apparently, the rewrites made the show feel more like a streaming series, and with the primary concerns addressed, reports suggest that the rewrite was well received by 20th TV and Searchlight TV, which seemed to get everyone on the same page that it’s a show that would most likely be picked up after filming this new pilot. The problem is, the new pilot never happened.

Erwich’s decision not to move forward with the pilot is another conundrum. Some say that once Hulu saw the rewrite, they felt it would be too expensive to shoot. Given that the initial concern was that it felt “too small,” it’s a bit baffling that it suddenly became too big to throw proper money into. Another reason that some believe played into their decision was that, even with the rewrite, Hulu believed it didn’t reach the level of the original show. If that’s the case, that’s more understandable. 

Still, if the ultimate decision comes from an executive, as Gellar put it, who wasn’t a fan of the original show and didn’t seem too keen on it from the start, one has to question whether he would be the one to know the high bar the original series set. It honestly feels like Buffy: New Sunnydale didn’t have a cheerleader in its corner from the start, which makes it even more interesting that Erwich, as head of Hulu Originals, would allow them to go through this lengthy development process when he allegedly wasn’t a fan of the IP to begin with.

Were Gellar’s Statements Honest or PR?

Some have said that Gellar’s statement, which placed the blame primarily on the executive for the project’s lack of progress, was more of a PR move to protect her brand, since she is known to have been heavily involved in this new version of Buffy from the start. An alleged copy of the original pilot has been making the rounds since the announcement, and some fans who have read it, should it be authentic, have been critical of the material and believe it may have been an ill-advised project since its announcement. 

The thing is, even if this is the true pilot script circulating on social media, it doesn’t reflect the supposed rewrite that received much better feedback from 20th TV and Searchlight TV. Somebody reportedly addressed these issues, and they were ready to give it another shot because they felt strongly about its potential.

Gellar isn’t the type to engage in media spin. She’s avoided controversy for her long career, and her heart has been in the right place for this sequel series since she announced it. We all know she’s fiercely dedicated to Buffy’s legacy, which explains why she’s said in several interviews that she didn’t want this to see the light of day until it was perfect. 

Zhao seems to have a partner who wanted to maintain that legacy, and the director’s comments and tone, that she was “not surprised” by Hulu’s decision to scrap the show during an interview on the Oscars red carpet, gave the impression that the series’ vision didn’t align with Hulu’s. Again, Hulu’s vision should’ve been included from the moment of development. With each passing day, evidence is growing that they weren’t as clear as they should’ve been.

The future of Buffy the Vampire Slayer remains uncertain. Reports suggest the powers that be want to take another run at the IP within the next couple of years. Some fans wondered whether the IP could go elsewhere, but 20th Television owns the Buffy IP and produced the original series. That means it remains under that umbrella, which Disney owns, so whatever incarnation of Buffy happens next will happen with them. It’s a shame that what was created out of love and meant to expand on the lore in a meaningful way fell apart, but maybe what’s next for Buffy represents the character’s resilience. She has faced many vampires, monsters, and demons and has come out on top every single time. Hell, she even beat death twice. If she can overcome that, maybe this isn’t the end of her story just yet.

For more on TV, make sure to check back to That Hashtag Show.

Keep Reading:

‘Ready Or Not 2: Here I Come’ Review – A Bloodier Sequel With Electric Performances