I am such a sucker for films that make their setting a character. The kind where the city itself is so integral to the story it can’t be made anywhere else. I also love a good 70s crime thriller, character-driven narratives packed with equal heart and thrills. Enter The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, a stylish love letter to all of the aforementioned loves with a terrific lead performance in John Turturro. It makes the most of its simple premise to present an engaging, endearing, and excellently paced thriller through the streets of New York and imbues its sentiment of that city and people in every frame.

From its grainy aesthetic to its life passed you by core, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is the best kind of ‘they don’t make ’em like they used to’ cinema. The nostalgic lens never stumbles into pretentious territory or misremembered history, feeling lived in presently as we follow a man stuck in his past life just trying to make it an unfamiliar world. Written and directed by Noah Segan, Turturro plays Harry, an aging pickpocket whose livelihood rests on a crime method that has become increasingly nonexistent. Unable to keep up with the ever changing landscape of the new New York and technology, Harry robs the wrong person. A young, unpredictable and connected punk who happens to be running crypto scams for a very powerful criminal enterprise.

After being tracked down, Harry is given a ticking clock to return the stolen goods before very bad things happen to his friends and family. The film also stars Steve Buscemi as a friendly but seedy pawn shop owner, Tatiana Maslany as Harry’s estranged daughter, Giancarlo Esposito as an aged-out detective and friend, and a surprise finale cameo I won’t spoil here even though you can find it anywhere else on the internet.

A Tried and True Throwback Crime Thriller

There is so much beauty in simplicity, and Only Living Pickpocket smartly mines the quieter moments to express deeper themes about growing old, the struggle for survival, and how quickly things can change around you whether you want them to or not. This is as simple as a premise can get; pickpocket steals from the wrong guy and now must right his wrongs, and somehow Segan manages to make it feel fresh and unique while clearly drawing inspirations from a plethora of 70s thrillers.

Turturro is so naturally New York, and guides us through his hardships and the city at large with ease. It’s impossible not to root for Harry, but also feel his pain and regret as he traverses the city streets in search of both items and time lost. There is a phenomenal heat check from Maslany here, who maybe has 5 minutes of screen time but makes a meal of it and shatters your heart into a million pieces. It’s always nice to see the softer side of Esposito too, who sheds his menace and villainous presence and becomes a confidant that shares in Harry’s longing for a simpler time.

It’s such a tricky balance to elevate something so simple like The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, and harder still to inject this much heart and character into a tried and true crime thriller. But Segan proves himself here and announces his arrival behind the camera after spending many years in front of it. Sam Levy’s exquisite cinematography cements the film inside of New York, bringing the city to life as a living, breathing entity.

His 70s construction makes the film feel timeless, existing both in the past and the present simultaneously. It’s all so tender in its character study and reflection on a bygone era, and never forgets to be thrilling and engaging amid its longing. It is brisk and well paced, succinctly executing on its simple premise to expand upon larger thematic musings that feel incredibly resonant.

Heart and Soul and An Ending that Sticks

Sticking the landing for something like this may be an even taller order than the execution of the film itself, and The Only Living Pickpocket in New York nails it with both feet together. Some may argue it wraps up in a nice bow a little too neatly, but I would push back and say that some of its bolder, more unexpected choices actually leaves you with something stronger to ponder, an ending that lingers longer after you take it all in and process its events. It’s more bittersweet than anything, but wholly encompasses the central themes of its story.

Heart and soul need to stay intact even when the climax needs to deliver thrills, and Only Living Pickpocket hits the mark with a beautiful balance of these two ideas. It’s patient, somber, funny, heartfelt and thrilling in all the right ways, mixing the ingredients in just the right measurements to be a surefire hit.

We all have that city we lived in, that city we love that we won’t ever leave but love to complain about. The city that you gave your life lived but took everything and isn’t the same anymore but there is nowhere else we would rather be. The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is the living embodiment of this sentiment, and becomes a film ease to love and hard to forget. This was a true surprise of Sundance, and a film I can’t wait to rewatch and get lost in again.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York had its world premiere at the 2026 Sundance Film Festival. It was picked up by Sony Pictures Classics and will be released in theaters later this year.

For more Reviews, make sure to check back to That Hashtag Show.

Keep Reading:

‘Hoppers’ Review – Pixar Hits Their Stride With Cute Animals