The Pitt Season 2 Review (Eps. 1-9): HBO Max’s Hit Medical Ensemble Makes A Well Earned Return

Note: At the time of this review, only nine of The Pitt Season 2’s 13 episodes were available for viewing. 

HBO Max’s The Pitt was seen as a streaming revelation when it debuted in January 2024. A hard-hitting medical drama that’s as intriguing as it was humane, executive producers Noah Wyle and R. Scott Gemmill appeared to have tapped into something audiences really wanted. The announcement of the second season felt inevitable, but may have left even the most optimistic of viewers.

The history of first-season hits that have gone downhill after renewal is probably what’s to blame for such thoughts. Those who enjoyed every second of The Pitt’s first rotation of patients, maladies, and workplace drama need not fear. Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center’s finest have scrubbed up yet again to provide a sophomore success that, hopefully, is the start of something larger. 

HBO Max’s 2024 sleeper streaming hit proves it’s no fluke in Season 2. 

As seen in The Pitt’s Season 2 trailer, the Fourth of July holiday is the latest backdrop for showrunner R. Scott Gemmill’s medical drama. Returning 10 months after Season 1’s PittFest shooting, the aftershocks are felt almost immediately, helping audiences feel like HBO Max‘s latest hit hasn’t missed a beat. 

Newcomers, like PTMC’s new attending physician Dr. Baran Al-Hashimi (Sepideh Moafi), find their rhythm easily among Dr. Robby (Noah Wyle) and his merry band of lifesavers. That perfectly complements the further blossoming of the residents and staff The Pitt introduced to us in Season 1 – all of whom have their own journeys ahead during the latest shift from hell. 

“Rhythm” is something that’s important to keep in mind with a series like The Pitt. Its nature as a medical drama in the real-time format requires dedication to keeping all the plates spinning, while also maintaining an overall storyline in the process. Whether you prefer binging an entire season as quickly as possible, or crave weekly cliffhangers, you’re in good hands. Ultimately, you’ll have to ask your doctor which method is right for you, as this series still has cliffhangers to tempt you into to hitting “Next Episode.”

The Pitt’s new batch of cases cement TV’s triumphant return to real-time drama.

Maintaining its real-time format from Season 1, The Pitt sidesteps a lot of the personal melodrama that some have come to loathe in medical shows. That’s not to say that personal relationships don’t have a place here. After all, executive producer John Wells has made a cottage industry with shows like The West Wing, Animal Kingdom – and yes, even ER, that relish such plotlines. 

With that elephant in the room, the difference between The Pitt and those titles, is that it maintains a laser focus on the moment at hand. Real-time drama forces a story’s hand in that way, as someone admitted at the beginning of the day could be a case that spans straight until the end of shift. 

The small snippets we hear about Dr. Santos (Isa Briones), Dr. King (Taylor Dearden), and the rest of the staff’s homelives are valuable, as it helps build these figures further – while also maintaining their profession’s integrity. The Pitt’s dedication also helps tackle messages that are so timely they’re “ripped from the headlines,” while also providing entertainment that’s only dated by the technology.

Everything from A.I. to insurance coverage, and immigration in-between, is handled through this trip to The Pitt. The choice of those storylines could be seen as a grab bag of the issues of the day, if it wasn’t for the deft handling of the material in Season 2’s overarching plot. Each patient, twist, or hiccup reveals more about Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center’s staff – even if the result isn’t totally explained through dialogue; which gives the entire cast moments that run the emotional gamut

Noah Wyle and company anchor what might be the most important scripted show on TV.

At a time where patients and professionals seem to carry their own slights by the system, The Pitt Season 2 furthers the case for the series as a candidate for the most important scripted drama on the air. The perils of medical bureaucracy are recognized on both sides, with physicians and first responders are honored, and patients given much empathy. All the while, the lack of sensationalism helps keep Season 2’s narrative just as sharp as before. 

That compliment is where future seasons of The Pitt will find the most difficulties. Ask anyone who remembers the era of 24, and they’ll tell you that the tighter the story, the more possibilities there are for derailment. Season 2’s final four episodes will be important to whether this program sticks the landing, or flatlines with no signs of life. Keeping that in mind, the prognosis is that The Pitt Season 2 primes this concept for long-term success, as opposed to becoming another flash in the pan.

Fans old and new can rest easy knowing that Season 2 is something that should be celebrated. Keeping the torch of mature, humane storytelling alive, it feels like a miracle to see it unfold as brilliantly as it has. Also, a case could be made for Noah Wyle’s Dr. Michael Robinavitch being a worthy successor to Kiefer Sutherland’s Jack Bauer; albeit with a kinder demeanor and interrogation style.

For more Reviews, make sure to check back to That Hashtag Show.

Keep Reading:

‘Stranger Things 5’ Finale Review – A Most Satisfying Ending To A Cultural Phenomenon